Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Cars

Here's another of those posts guaranteed to be of no interest to anyone except a couple family members and maybe my ex-wife. (Originally posted 8/8/2010.)

I used to keep a journal on the computer, a practice I began at the start of my flying career and kept on through various trials and job changes. When I met Susan I found that after keeping her up to date with my daily doings I didn't have the energy to go over everything again for posterity, and my diarizing gradually faded away. Then I somehow managed to lose the file--and every backup of it--so that the several-thousand-page record of these years, such as it was, is now lost. (Actually, this blog is just an attempt to transfer this on again / off again daily habit to a more public--and maybe more durable--forum.)

One of the files I kept up along with my daily journal (alas, now also lost) was a record of the various cars and trucks I had owned over the years. (There was a separate file for motorcycles.) Writing this now, I feel immediately defensive at the stupidity of this and the appearance of shameless consumerism. But I must own my car fetish. For whatever reason, I tend to get restless with a car after 18 months or so and I start trolling the car lots and magazines, shopping for the next thing. Though I do love a new car, many of my vehicles over the years--a majority of them--have been used. But clearly making the best use of money has not been the object of my automotive strategy (if you can call it that). And, as I know I've said elsewhere, even now I can't think of much I'd rather do with this money than to have had a couple dozen cars. My car file was in no way an attempt to boast about these cars--very few of them were anything to be especially proud of; but over the years there grew to be such a number of vehicles that I feared losing track of them or of their characteristics or of our history together. And so I started keeping a record.

I've included many of my spouses' cars here, since I tend to be the primary driver when I'm around and I often used their cars as my own (and vice-versa, of course) and I was instrumental in all of these purchases.

Unless specifically noted, none of these photos are from my actual cars. I'm a little surprised to find that I don't have many pictures of these cars over the years. And it's more surprising yet, actually, how difficult it is to find a web photo of exactly the make and model and year and color of vehicles which presumably sold originally in the tens or hundreds of thousands. So I've tried to use the photo that comes closest to the model and equipment, and color has taken a back seat. Maybe I'll make it a mission now to look for photos that exactly match my old cars, or to snap those photos myself when I run across a better example than what I've found thus far.

Without further ado:

  1. 1970 Buick Riviera (purchased 1979). Gold with, maybe, a white or black landau top (sad, I can't remember and I doubt there are any photographs). My first car. Had a 455CI engine with a 4bbl carburetor & 3-speed automatic. No Positraction. Bought before my junior prom from dealer where Tanner's used to be in Brainerd. Traded my mildly-crashed Honda CB400 Hawk motorcycle for it. Drove through my Jr. and Sr. years of high school, and in the summer after graduation my brother Jon drove it up to Hackensack and back and failed to accommodate its prodigious consumption of oil. Overheated and cracked the water pump. Junked @186,000 miles at Shipman Auto in BRD (thus saving me the question of where to put it when I went down to MSP to college).

  2. 1977 Pontiac Bonneville (acquired in '81 or '82). Dark red. 350CI V8, crushed red velvet interior. My dad's car, bought new in '77 and given to me after my first year of college to sell for a motorcycle for an adventure. I used it at college in MSP for part of that year and then sold it to a dealer in Brainerd for, I think, $2300.



  3. 1972 Cadillac Coupe de Ville. Black. 500CI V8. After my motorcycle trip, bought in Pine River (I think). Drove for less than a year. Turns out it had been so cheap because the heater core was gone and it was an expensive fix; no heater in MN winter = bad. Drove it (in a snowmobile suit) across the frozen lakes around Brainerd at high speeds--we'd get to maximum speed and then spin the overboosted steering wheel and hang on. Junked it with a couple friends, driving it around town in various states of disassembly until it was just an engine and frame and rear fenders. Gave it to an old junk collector out in the woods around Nisswa.




  4. 1981 Ford Escort (my ex-wife's). Gold or tan & brown 2-tone. Bought used by her dad. 5-speed. Quite junky but reliable nonetheless. Needed CV joints @ about 60K miles as I recall.




  5. 1974 Volvo 142. Garish orange exterior and an interior striped like a beach umbrella. Bought in MSP about 1984. 4-speed manual, coupe. Huge tractor-like steering wheel and stubby shifter with square knob. Not an ounce of performance but built solid like a tank. The most road personality of any car I'd owned before or since. Mechanical fuel injectors as noisy as a diesel. The Swedes at their best: would start in the coldest weather without plugging in (it had no plug) and produced heat almost instantly, even at -40. Simple and very versatile heat controls. But it was always about 25% broke: over a year or so it needed two heater blower motors, three drive shaft universal joints, brakes, etc. Bought my first new truck and sold the Volvo off the street (Cedar Ave. & 46th St.) for a few bucks.





  6. 1985 Toyota 2WD x-tra cab pickup. Bought new from dealer up in Brooklyn Park for, I believe, about $7,500; my first new car. Blue, 5-speed, 4-cylinder. Bucket seats and opening rear window the only options. Simple and robust. Totaled not long after purchase while driving home from morning bus run at the MTC. My fault. Wipers were smearing ice on the windshield and I fixated and did not notice the stalled traffic ahead. No injuries, but totaled both cars.




  7. 1980 (I think) Oldsmobile 98. Burnt orange. Bought from dealer in Roseville for, I think, $4000. They touted its low mileage (47,000!). When it used a lot of oil I did a title search at the DOT in STP and found the correct mileage figure was 147,000. Got money back after the dealer demanded I sign an I-don't-know-how-many-miles-it-has disclaimer (even though I did know; I just wanted my money back).




  8. 1986 Toyota 2WD x-tra cab pickup (new). Bright red, same model as above, except with bench seats instead of buckets. Decided the used car wasn't all the savings I had hoped. This truck spent a couple years hauling equipment around for the band I was in, The Steaming Jacuzzis. (No photo here; the above photo for the '85 is actually my '86 truck almost exactly.)


  9. 1987 Mazda RX-7 (new). Blue metallic. Traded above truck in, leased the Mazda. Base model with alloy wheels, fabulous wankel rotary motor and 5-speed. $16,800 sticker, payments were $385, a fortune for me at the time. I quickly exceeded the lease's meager mileage allotment and sold the car at a big loss to avoid a bigger one. Ergo, my first lease and, until I'm driving far fewer miles, my last one. (It seems there's no way to put more mouths to feed in the expense chain and not ultimately pay more money.)

  10. 1980 Chevrolet Impala (Caprice?) wagon. Dark green. 305 CID V-8. Bought used in Pine River as a means of trying to keep miles off the Mazda. Paid, I think, about $1,400. We called it "The Green Weenie." Actually, a great do-everything car. Became my dad's car when I was done with it.




  11. 1985 Toyota Corolla GTS coupe (Ex-wife's, bought used by her dad). Silver. A fun little car but horrid for a MN winter with its RWD, light weight and wide hot-rod tires. Don't remember what became of it--sale or trade-in or maybe her dad just took it back and disposed of it. (This photo is a non-hot-rod version.)




  12. 1986 Honda Civic (Ex-wife's, bought new, I believe). Became my car when she got the Subaru below (I was still recovering from the Mazda lease debacle). Gold metallic. 5-speed. Very lightly built, but a blast to drive and trouble-free until we got rid of it around the 90,000 mile mark.




  13. 1988 Subaru wagon (Ex-wife's, became mine when she got Subaru below). This model was later called the Loyale. White. Automatic, FWD (not AWD). Bought slightly used from Poquet Auto up in Pine River. Utterly gutless but fairly utilitarian. Trouble-free for us. Gave to my dad, who drove it past 225,000 miles despite continuous trouble with the cooling system. (This photo has a strangely raised roof; ours did not.)




  14. 1991 Toyota 2WD x-tra cab pickup (slightly used). Dark red w/ windowless topper. Looked like a red hearse. Got in an accident with this one also, nearly totaling it. It was never quite right afterward. Hauled a lot of stuff while building a house up in Nisswa. Had this the longest of any car to date, over three years. Traded in on next Toyota truck.




  15. 1991 Subaru Legacy sedan (Ex-wife's). Again purchased slightly used from Poquet Auto. A kind of really deep gold / brown metallic that looked black. Shiny, camel-hair-color interior, the fabric for which (I remember a reviewer noting) looked like "the pelts of carnival teddy bears." Auto, FWD. Nice car, but lousy seats.




  16. 1995 Subaru Outback wagon (Ex-wife's). Purchased new or near-new (possibly from Poquet Auto again in Pine River). Red w/ tan 2-tone. Our first AWD / 4WD car. A great MN winter car, though later models with more ground clearance and more aggressive tires were even better in the snow--the earliest one was a mostly cosmetic exercise compared to the basic Legacy.




  17. 1995 1/2 Toyota Tacoma 4WD x-tra cab pickup. Bought new, this time from a dealer down in Burnsville. Red. 4 cylinder like the previous trucks, but my first with 4WD. 5-speed.




  18. 1997 Dodge Ram 4WD extended cab pickup (new). White, with gray cloth interior. 318 CID V-8. This truck remains one of my favorite vehicles of all, but the mileage was tough @ 30,000+ miles a year. Getting rid of it for mileage purposes, though, was stupid since I lost more money on the transaction than the gas would have cost over the life of ownership.




  19. 1998 Dodge Intrepid (new). Dark green metallic. Nicely equipped, though without the leather I'd wanted. Good radio. Come winter--and after a couple beachings in all of 5" of snow--I missed the 4WD and not having to fret about weather on my cross-the-Midwest drives for my airline work. My current car when I met Susan; she remembers our first date in it.




  20. 1998 Jeep Cherokee Sport. Green. Susan's car when I met her in Fargo, her first new car, bought on a 2-year lease in Appleton. Auto, with an inline 6. Peppy but crude, and had a series of little niggling problems--doorstop breakages, front end seals. For the record, she insists this is STILL the greatest car ever made (except that it isn't--she'd take her Honda now anyday).

  21. 2000 Toyota Tacoma 4WD V-6 xtra-cab pickup (new). Yet another red Toyota, and another 5-speed. Traded the Dodge Intrepid on it. First stick shift car Susan drove--I had to teach her (very nicely, tho there were still tears! And then tears when we got rid of it. Go figure). After her 1998 Jeep Cherokee lease expired shortly before our wedding this became our primary car. (No photo; again, very like the 1995 above except for the V6, which only carried a small badge on the tailgate.)

  22. 2001 Saturn L200 sedan (new). Gold metallic. 4 cylinder, automatic. Leather interior, heated seats, sunroof. Nice car and trouble-free for us (though I suspect it would not have aged terribly well). (Ours did not have the alloy wheels in the picture below.)




  23. 1981 Cadillac Seville. 2-tone gold / brown. Bought out of some guy's front yard on Kaukauna's Northside for $1,000. Very used (150K+). Big history of extracting repair penalties from its owner, but was mostly trouble-free for the several years I had it (excepting that only about 50% of its accessories ever worked at any given time. It helped to have a good mechanic adept at the $20 band-aid fix). Heavy and lazy with a grumbling 368CI V-8 and severely overboosted steering, this car's element was the open road, and it made numerous 500-mile trips between Louisville and Appleton over the years. Lived in Louisville at the end. Blew a radiator in the Galyan's parking lot and the fix was determined to exceed the car's value. Sent to the crusher on a flatbed (I still have pictures somewhere).




  24. 2004 Saturn Vue V-6 AWD (new). Red. Snappy 3.5L Honda V6. A functional but unimpressive vehicle. The seat heaters gave up after the first year or so. Traded the Saturn L200 on it. All our Saturn experiences were made happy less by the cars, which were only adequate, than by a first-rate dealer and excellent customer service.




  25. 1997 Buick Riviera. Dark red. Traded my Honda Superhawk on it (ironically at "Great Lakes Auto" in Darboy). Actually a pretty cool car. Every option: leather, sunroof, heated seat, seat & mirror memory, cruise, good stereo, automatic climate control. Extraordinarily quiet; the perfect freeway car--like my old Seville but with just a dash of Monte Carlo chic. Fabulous, sensuous lines. But a real hangar queen. Stickered for $35K new; I bought it with seven years and 73,000 miles on the clock for $11K. Three years later it was worth $500 on trade. Needed three sets of brakes, two A/C compressors, a zillion other $500 items. When the "heavy duty" transmission gave up at 125,000 miles, I cried uncle.




  26. 2006 Honda Civic EX coupe (new). Blue metallic. 5-speed, great radio, sunroof. A mini-Riviera without the latter's constant financial bloodletting. A great car, but light and small; a bit snug for a fat guy. Good mileage, tho (38 MPG highway). Traded on Flex.




  27. 2008 Honda Element (new). Bright lime green metallic. AWD. Traded the Saturn Vue on it. Quirky but very utilitarian, the do-everything car. Drives OK, has good radio, and gets through anything in winter. Susan's current car, and her favorite thus far.




  28. 2009 Ford Flex (new). Black. Limited, AWD. Every option but navigation. Thus far (presently @25,000 miles) I have to say it's my favorite single vehicle of the lot. As quiet as my Riviera and very smooth. Great winter car, and very comfy for 4 or even 6 people. (For once, an actual photo of my car.)




  29. 1998 Ford F150. White, 2WD, 4.2L V6. 133,000 miles. Work truck, w/ no options whatsoever. No A/C, no cloth seats, no carpet, no cruise, no opening rear window. Bought to live in Louisville as my airporter (now that I'm back on reserve), but it needed to be roadworthy enough to make the 500 mile drive when required. Alas, it survived but the trip down to KY before throwing its motor. This photo was our last together. $3G down the drain. (This has rekindled my skepticism of American cars; I may have to vent in a separate post.)


  30. 2011 Ford Taurus SHO. Metallic Slate Gray. Got as a slightly-used dealer demo. Traded the Flex on it in July of 2011. Just about every option known to humanity: navigation, adaptive cruise control, heated / airconditioned / massaging seats, automatic wipers, automatic headlights / high beams, backup camera, blind spot warning system, collision alert, rear / side collision alert, SYNC voice control. Twin turbo "Ecoboost" 3.5 liter V-6 good for 365 hp and 400 ft/lbs of torque. Spirited performance, but perhaps even quieter than the Flex. The perfect highway car.
(Not my car, but same color.)

31. 2014 Ford F150. FX4 package (at that time, its own trim level; later the FX4 became a package added to whatever trim level purchased. Mine was based off of Lariat trim). Extended cab, so not full rear seats. 3.5L Ecoboost twin-turbo V6. Fabulous power, good transmission. Very comfortable seats--maybe the best seats I've had. Very quiet on the highway. Nicely equipped, but missing a couple key features. No adaptive cruise (was not offered by Ford on the trucks until 2015), no navigation. But for these I could have kept the car forever. Leased and then purchased at the end of the lease. My favorite car of all.



32. 2016 Honda CR-V Touring, white. Traded the Element for it--to my wife's eternal chagrin. Same running gear as the Element, but in a more civilized package. Touring trim had everything: adaptive cruise, navigation, heated leather, sunroof, AWD. And it *is* the most popular SUV sold in this country. But... (and maybe I'm just becoming a horrible snob) I just don't feel like any of it quite added up to a home run. The navigation was unusable as a directive device (though OK as a moving map display); the adaptive cruise was so slow and cautious as to make one a road hazard; the seats were nice, but not F-150 nice; it was quieter than the Element, but not especially quiet. Etc. Became my airport car after Susan discovered the glories of the Jeep (see below), and I sold it to a dealer in MKE.

(not mine)


33. 2017 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited. Sahara trim level. I intended to buy something inexpensive for a Louisville car and (because my wife had never liked the Honda CR-V) it kind of morphed into this Jeep (which she HAD always liked). 6-speed manual, removable hard top. Heated seats, power windows. Otherwise, pretty basic. Noisy and fairly crude, but kinda fun to drive and more comfortable than one would expect. Great seat heaters and a fabulous cabin heater.



34. 2019 RAM 1500 4X4 crew cab. Laramie trim. Heated and cooled leather seats, automatic everything (lights, high beams, wipers), adaptive cruise, 12" center screen with navigation. My first time ordering specifically from the factory--even came with my name on the sticker! Traded the F-150. I really struggled with this decision, as I had loved my F-150 so much. My plan was to buy another Ford. But the interior of this RAM made me roll the dice. The RAM's V-8 sounds like a million bucks (the F-150 alway sounds like a sewing machine) but makes less power than the Ford--though pretty close. Markedly worse mileage. Rotary shift knob makes for a huge center storage console, but the switch doesn't always manage to put the truck in gear as expected. No external keypad like the Ford, but an app that lets you do as much and more from your phone. A much more ambitious options package, but not all of it seems fully worked out. The wipers, for example, don't always work and cannot be made to work until they've worked thru their issues.




35. 2023 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited, Willys trim. My wife's car, we traded her previous Jeep on this one, which seems to have been upgraded in significant ways. The interior pieces seem to have followed in the above Ram's footsteps (being from the same parent company, after all), with a significant jump in quality over the 2017. Knobs and switches seem higher quality, the dash seems more coherent and with some soft-touch surfaces, and the seats seem slightly upgraded. It retains its amazing seat heaters, and it produces heat on a cold day faster than any car I've had since my old Volvo. Same engine--the 3.7 liter Pentastar V-6--but with an upgraded transmission--upgraded in that it shifts much better, and because it's rod-actuated the shift lever does not jump around over bumps. But about that transmission: the gear ratios are clearly chosen for economy, and the top two gears are next to worthless. I routinely find myself on the highway at 70 in fourth gear, and the engine is still spinning only about 2,100 rpms. And in sixth gear, even a tepid headwind slows the car down. Passing is absolutely impossible. This is the one car where I feel an automatic would be a great idea. It's fun enough around town, but a pain in the neck on the highway. It's quite noisy (REALLY noisy until we traded out the aggressive mud & snow tires for some more highway-oriented rubber), and it blows around in the wind and doesn't track very well. But so far it's been trouble free.




36. 2023 Ford F150 Lightning. There's a lengthy post about this vehicle here. Traded the Ram on this, and before taking a test drive I expected to buy another Ram. But the electric powertrain absolutely won me over, and I could sense that I was doing my 500 mile commute less and less as I gained seniority, and I decided to take a chance. As it happens, I only drove the truck back and forth from KY maybe four or five times before my retirement arrived. In the end, I just fell head-over-heels in love with electric propulsion, and I feel I'll never go back. The quiet and clean of it, the effortless and crazy amount of power, the refueling at home, the comparative cheapness to run it (so long as I'm not driving cross-country, where the cost is about the same as gasoline), the lack of maintenance--all these things put me firmly and permanently in the EV camp. I did have one major repair on it, a blown Gateway Module just out of warranty that cost me $3000. As it happens, the flaw was not EV-related--there's a Gateway Module on every F150--so the extended coverage of EV components was no help. Beyond that, it was trouble-free for 65,000 miles.




37. 2026 Rivian R1T. "Half Moon Gray." Purchased online and picked up in Chicago--since WI has a law prohibiting car manufacturers from selling in the state; an independent dealer must cover that task. About 1/3 of states have this rule, and it applies to Tesla and Lucid and others. In anticipation (I think) of that rule being overturned, Rivian recently opened a "demo and service center" in Appleton, and I was able to go there and take the truck for a test drive. My "sales person" kind of did everything a dealer might do except the legal stuff. I traded the Lightning on this, which was not an easy decision for me since I loved the Lightning so much. But with Ford having discontinued the vehicle (if they'd had a new / upgraded version, I'd have bought that), and with the future servicing and software support questions seeming unsettled, I felt it was not a bad idea to move to an all-EV manufacturer. Plus, we needed a truck and the Rivian is really about the only show in town. There's a nice Silverado EV available, but I'm unsure about  GM and the American EV future. The Rivian is really fabulous to drive, and it's easily the most technologically advanced vehicle I've owned--taking a big step beyond the Lightning. What remains to be seen for us is whether the size is sufficient for how we use it (it's a little bigger than a Toyota Tacoma, maybe a little smaller than a Ford Ranger). It has a touch more power than the Lightning, and almost exactly the same range. It has a heat pump, which should help its winter range, but near as I can tell, it'll parallel what the Lightning delivered almost to the T.




Tuesday, August 18, 2026

Capitalism Gone Wild

Here’s another in my long list of posts labeled Old Man Grapples With Philosophical And Political Concepts More Properly Digested In High School.


So I watched a video a couple days ago on the YouTube channel Connecting The Dots about the auto industry, specifically about the industry’s shift to Electric Vehicles. The video talked about all the challenges involved in this transition, and especially about two of the big players, Toyota and Ford, who, he says, are facing a life or death moment. I drive an EV, and the inevitability of the world transitioning to this technology is not news to me. And I think it's abundantly clear that the legacy auto industry will need to retool how it works. But I haven’t really thought out the details, and it turns out there are devils in those details. And some of the details of the transition are like the pork secretly hidden in an appropriations bill in Washington, incidental yet fraught with consequences unintended by the original impetus.


I’ve had a Ford F150 Lightning electric pickup as my daily driver now for over three years. I loved it—like, crazy love!—at first drive, and after 60,000 miles I remain absolutely smitten. The Lightning is brilliant for daily use, and my hat goes off to Ford for the engineering involved. Three years in I have almost no complaints of any kind—and this from a guy who is normally looking at new cars before a year has elapsed on the current one. This truck is my favorite of the 50+ vehicles I owned before it—by quite a margin. I’m actually still excited every day to have an excuse to go drive it. But it was a very ambitious undertaking for Ford, a step away from much of the institutional knowledge they’d accumulated over a century. It’s an expensive vehicle, and even at the eye-watering sticker price the sale did not cover the costs to the company for producing it. But this was part of the pain of transition, right? The world was changing Ford was wrestling with that change. My truck was proof. 


But then about a year ago, after four years of production, Ford abruptly canceled the Lightning leaving them with the Mustang Mach-E as their only EV. They also halted construction on a big battery plant and announced that present EV plans were being curtailed (they cautioned that the change did NOT mean they were abandoning electrification; but what DID it mean?). This was shocking and profoundly disappointing to me. I had joined a new and exciting club, and now Ford looked to be retreating from all that, and the alternative path was just so obviously a dead end. Cue the huge sad trombone as the air left the balloon. Yes, there might be profit in the short term with ICE and hybrids, but long term the world will sing a different tune, and the big task must be undertaken. (None of this was helped by the stupefying Trump Administration faceplant as it implemented, among its endless stream of multiple daily faceplants, its Project 2025 self-immolating war on climate science and green energy. The tax credits that were intended to help the auto industry work through the immense costs of the changeover were abruptly withdrawn, and chaos and uncertainty became the order of the day—in cars as in everything else these people touched. The switch to EVs was underway in Europe, and China is WAY ahead. And we’re still stuck on Drill, Baby, Drill, falling further and further behind.)


Toyota and Honda—of which I’ve owned many examples—were a whole different flavor of disappointing. They didn’t just misread the winds, they seemed to refuse to read the winds altogether. They showed no interest in EVs at all—which is especially baffling when both were early developers of hybrids, and Toyota with the Prius brought at least partial electrification prominently to the mainstream 20 years before anyone else. And yet the next logical step seemed not to interest them. It’s like orbiting the moon and having no thought to land on it. Both companies made half-hearted attempts at an EV or two and then… Look At Our New Hybrid! About the same time that Ford killed the Lightning, Honda announced it was pulling the plug on a trio of ambitious EVs, and very recently Toyota announced the abrupt cancellation of their coming flagship Lexus EV, leaving us in both cases with an uninspired old school lineup. Even as Toyota chalked up 11 million sales last year making them the largest carmaker in the world by quite a margin, their CEO made a recent public speech saying that the company was in a death match with China and if it did not radically rework how it operated it would not survive—again, this in the midst of very healthy sales. On the surface, none of this adds up.


Well, they’re reading the winds now. The Connecting The Dots video addressed all this, dissecting what is afoot at both Ford and at Toyota. And his conclusion is that both companies have had the same realization that the industry is in an existential crisis, and each is attempting to avert disaster—albeit in rather different ways.


The key player in this drama—the wrench in the machine, if you like—is Tesla. Not only did Tesla almost single-handedly turn the electric car into a viable household item, but in the process—and as part and parcel of the product itself—the company radically reworked the whole car business. I mean, everything: the basic car design, the process of designing it, the building of it, how it’s fueled, how it’s sold, even how it’s driven. The gloom and doom from Ford and Toyota can be traced almost directly to each company’s dissection of a Tesla Model 3. After that it was obvious to both that a complete ground-up reworking stood between the present day and the companies’ survival. (I wonder how many such tectonic shifts there have been in history, ones affecting such large industries, so many people, so many billions of dollars?)


So what is this shift and why is it so disruptive? My Lightning is a second generation product of a legacy industry, a company adapting to a new reality. By the inception of the Lightning, Ford could already see that electrification was coming and would take over. And so the company began retooling for what management expected the new reality to look like. Generation 1 EVs from the legacy builders involved swapping electric components into existing ICE drivetrains. Put a battery where the gas tank was, and an electric motor where the gas engine was. Ford’s first serious EV, the Focus Electric, was just that: an ICE car with electric components swapped in. My truck, and the Mustang Mach-E, were Generation 2: new conventional vehicles with purpose-built electric drivetrains in place of ICE components, not a revolution but mostly familiar cars designed by legacy engineering teams and built more or less on existing factory lines. With the Lightning, Ford took its single biggest selling product, the F150 pickup, one with a healthy profit margin the buyers of which expect to write big checks, and banked on those characteristics being able to shoulder the burdens of these changes to the company and the industry.


But Tesla was playing a different game entirely. They started with a clean sheet and reworked *everything,* and their innovations made this whole legacy structure untenable. The design team, materials acquisition, the factory layout, the supply chain, the assembly protocols, the marketing approach, the sales model; none of the old ideas worked in Tesla’s new world, at least not without a ground-up rethink. And Ford and Toyota could now see this. This is why the Lightning was killed, not because it wasn’t a good vehicle, but because scaling this technology and these manufacturing methods was just scaling a fundamentally inefficient methodology, ensuring bigger and bigger losses, digging a deeper hole. The new approach was just vastly more efficient on all fronts. And both companies could see that without reworking to this new reality they were on the ropes. As it killed the Lightning, Ford announced some $19 billion in write-downs for its EV transition, and now admitted they were on the wrong track. $19 billion! And what they could now see was the real work was not yet done. In fact, the crucial bits were not even started. But if we dig down, the efficiencies found by Tesla are not without knock-on effects. I have questions.


What Ford must rework, exactly? The video identifies four “anchors” which he says are “dragging Ford down to the depths,” to wit: 


1) Union contracts, 

2) Pensions, 

3) The “Wall Street trap,” and 

4) The dealership model (which he calls the “dealership mafia”). 


If China—and then Tesla—don’t have to abide by union contracts nor pay pensions to retired employees, obviously their costs are substantially reduced. Cars made under that model will undoubtedly be cheaper. The extensive use of robots eliminates even more costly employees. So is that the end of it, to be successful we just have to eliminate employees? But who SHOULD pay pensions to retirees? How SHOULD older people sustain themselves? What protections SHOULD workers have? Whose prerogatives should be honored? (And are the costs of Ford’s vast management structure not similarly a liability? Surely AI can do the work of a middle-manager as well as it can run a welding robot.) Why is it OK for money to go into the pockets of shareholders, but money going to the people, you know, actually doing the work is a waste?


As to dealerships, for as long as I’ve been paying attention they have been floated as a prime cause of the failure of EVs to take root here. As the video points out, dealerships make their money not in selling cars, but predominantly in repairs and maintenance, both of which are much curtailed by the mechanical simplicity and basic operation of an EV. So naturally, the dealers are reluctant to sell them, or they stick high markups on the sticker price (when I bought my Lightning, the dealer was quite frantic to get me into a hybrid or ICE truck and I had to insist on the EV. They really didn’t want to sell me one. Maybe not coincidentally, the sales guy who gave me my test drive knew far less about the truck than I did). What to make of this? Are the dealers insane for not wanting their business to suffer or for maintenance jobs to go away? Is it just inevitable that progress puts all jobs out to pasture? I recall that when diesels came to the railroad industry and supplanted steam power in the 1930s-40s, something like 90% of the maintenance staff got let go. Of course the idea of continuing with steam power just to keep maintenance guys in jobs was not the answer. Surely the solution to progress is not to entrench needless inefficiency. But where does it lead? Do we end up with 100% robotic factories, machines with AI brains building the other machines? And what happens to the profits from that new approach? I can see value in getting rid of most of the dealership networks, but it’s not surprising that those workers do not want to vanish quietly.


And lastly, the Wall Street Trap, the need for Ford to remain a stable, blue-chip stock that people can buy to reliably prop up their portfolio. That seems another whole can of worms having nothing specifically to do with the car industry, and it feels to me like we’re looking at a very specific pathogen in a petrie dish—one which I suspect has quietly metastasized throughout our whole culture. I have long felt that pleasing shareholders—that is, rewarding the people who have gambled some of their excess and unneeded money hoping that money will make them MORE money—has become the tail that is manically wagging the dog, to the point that it's shaking the dog apart. The notion that sensible and responsible retirement strategy now consists of large scale institutionalized gambling—a setup which looks suspiciously like it was dreamed up entirely for someone else’s benefit—seems insanity itself. But I simply don’t know enough about business and banking and taxation and any of it to feel very informed in my opinions. 


I just don’t know what to do with this information, especially when the pathway to set workers aside is being advocated by the world’s richest man, one who could divvy out half his yearly income to the people at his factories doing the actual work, to genuine benefit to them and virtually no pain to himself. But—surprise!—the notion of widespread profit sharing is not part of the Big Change discussions. Talking up that option is not part of the coordinated response from the MSM—who are, not coincidentally, owned by exactly the same billionaires who sent American manufacturing jobs overseas. CEO-to-worker pay ratios have never been so divergent as they are now, and the complex pay packages and hidden bonuses and off-the-books perks and crazy tax laws are now kind of the whole playbook of big business. Political conservatism seems always to have been at odds with democratic self-government, a small cadre of rich elites have always worked to keep outsize control over the worlds in which they live --tho glee from those in power at the suffering their greed caused has not always been such a big part of the picture. (And all this is quite separate from questions of unlimited riches and political influence in the hands of sociopaths while we hope they'll do the best for us.)


But is this what ails the American auto industry? Or is this just the pain of progress?


What’s the alternative? Artificial make-work to keep people employed? Even when, especially when, the jobs could be done faster and cheaper and better with automation? But faster and cheaper to what end? Musk has said that automation will take over most jobs in short order; what does that look like? Are the people making this prediction, the people working for its implementation, in favor of a Universal Basic Income? Communism, the bogeyman of economics in the West, is supposed to take from each according to their ability and give according to their needs. Where does UBI fit into this scheme? Is it not the ultimate thing for the right to hate? Or will the machines just quietly eliminate us from the equation altogether? (I mean, even better than machines making cars for us would be machines not needing to make cars for us—or roads or any automotive infrastructure.)

I see now that the Connecting the Dots site has even more dire predictions for GM. But that's another post.

Monday, December 29, 2025

The Law of Unintended Consequences

I wrote a post a few years back which I did not publish about the saga of being fitted with a CPAP machine and its implications for my working life. I recently deleted that draft, since (as I’ve mentioned several times—and will doubtless keep mentioning) I’ve decided to start my clock to retirement, which fact makes the whole issue moot.

Or so I thought. I guess I just didn’t think hard enough.

The issue a few years back was this: I’ve been overweight my whole life, hovering around the BMI figure where in my career as an airline pilot I might be evaluated for sleep apnea. The FAA looks at BMI and neck size (not sure how they know this figure) and blood pressure and determines whether further scrutiny is warranted. So my AME (Aviation Medical Examiner) for years would tell me “You’re right on the line for needing a sleep apnea evaluation, so don’t gain any more weight! Better, yet, you ought to lose 15 pounds and you won’t have to worry about it.” I never gave the issue much thought, since I know I do not have sleep apnea. I have the most challenging sleep circumstance of anyone I know, and if I were suffering from sleep issues I’d sure as hell be the one to know it (to say nothing of the guarantee that my wife, the world’s lightest sleeper, would march my ass to the doctor the morning after she heard me gasping in my sleep). I was confident that if I were evaluated for sleep apnea I’d be cleared.

But that’s not how the game works.

Well, my old AME that I had used for 15 plus years ended up dying from COVID. (That’s another post—he had fallen down some rancid Alex Jones rathole and had decided that, despite having several big risk factors and despite formal training in virology and infection, he would eschew traditional medical practices and “protect” himself with a magic key fob around his neck that emitted some kind of magic Jesus Wave that warded off the evil viral spirits. And Darwin came calling.) So I found a new AME. And that guy, unbeknownst to me, was actually a pulmonologist in real life. So if anything were to happen to me medically in my job that warranted any kind of investigation, this guy would have ho place to hide. He would not be able to say (as the last guy, a retired dermatologist, might have done) “Yeah, I looked at him but he assured me he was fine.” The FAA would call it dereliction of duty that a pulmonologist didn’t report a fat guy for a sleep apnea evaluation.

And so the certified letter from the FAA duly came, and after 28 years of flying without incident I found myself headed to a sleep clinic. This seems bad enough, though it’s a fair question to ask whether some scrutiny is not warranted and when that line might be crossed. But I wasn’t unduly worried, as I knew I had no sleep issues.

But strangely enough, nobody ever asked me about my sleep issues and habits. What I thought or wanted, and what my experiences were, was of no interest to anybody. I was given two separate evaluations and found to have no obstruction, no diminution of my blood oxygen. So, good, right? Well, only if the results of the tests actually mattered. But no, they prescribed a CPAP machine regardless, despite my vocal protests that such a therapy would be EXTREMELY intrusive in my line of work. My objections were met with stiffer and stiffer resistance, eventually bordering on abuse. I had the distinct impression that the staff were used to fielding objections and had ready responses to them. (As the controversy escalated, I contacted our pilots’ union for advice and was told “Oh yeah, if you are evaluated for sleep apnea then you’re getting a CPAP machine. The results of the test don’t matter.” It would have been nice to know this information beforehand.)

In all, I was out of work for five and a half months while this all got sorted (the diagnosis of sleep apnea caused me to lose my medical until such time as the FAA granted a “special issuance” medical with the condition listed) so I had the summer of 2023 off for literally no practical reason, though it did let me take retirement for a test-drive. (We do have loss of license insurance, so I was able to pay my bills, but the leave of absence was nonetheless a pretty substantial pay hit.)

Fast forward to today. I was able to get my special issuance medical (there are loads of CPAP machines among airline pilots) and I returned to work about 10 months ago and have been steaming along since. In the back of my mind, I’ve been looking forward to the escape valve of retirement when I can jettison the unneeded and unwanted CPAP machine—along with freedom from all the other bits of intrusive scrutiny the job entails. But I hadn’t properly considered what this might look like going forward. If I intend to do ANY flying in retirement—even recreationally, to say nothing of potential side work—then I’m going to need to qualify for a medical. And now I have a historical diagnosis of Obstructive Sleep Apnea on my record (despite my pointedly NOT having Obstructive Sleep Apnea). To procure that medical (of whatever class) I’m going to have to present documentation that I’ve been using the CPAP machine for the entire preceding year. It’s not something I can fudge; the machine itself tracks its usage and reports it via its own cellular connection to my medical facility, which then provides the documentation to the FAA. It’s VERY big brother.

I’m not a medical skeptic, though I certainly believe that big pharma needs regulating just as big business and free markets absolutely do. But this little CPAP wormhole seems like a scam, an iron-clad way for the clinic and supporting structures to get their cut of a $1000 machine and yearly visits (I am contacted every six months and solicited to take my box of insurance-approved replacement supplies—hoses and masks and filters—all at no cost to me! Thus the medical supply company pockets another $600). 

I do this or I stop flying. Those are my options.

I decided that playing along was the easiest option for my last year or two, but a part of me would like to do my part in dismantling the whole rotten enterprise. Don’t get me wrong, I know sleep apnea IS a thing, and if one has it then I understand this technology can be life-changing. But the bar seems to be set very low, and the hooks are very deep. They put me in charge of a $200 million machine but I’m not allowed to assess my own sleep life.

For now I'm content to stay out of the cockpit. If I decide I'd like to fly again, I *may* be able to hold a third class medical without reference to the sleep apnea. But I wouldn't be able to be paid to fly. So maybe I can find a sleep doctor who will play ball with me and get my diagnosis expunged. Or maybe I start using the damned machine again. But I doubt it.

Sunday, December 28, 2025

The Spice of Life



I started playing the drums in the school band in fourth or fifth grade. Mrs. Franklin (I think) was the band teacher at Nisswa elementary school, and I remember announcing to her on a whim that I was maybe interested in playing in the band. “Maybe? Or you’re interested?” she asked. So I had to commit. And when she began suggesting instruments I picked drums without hesitation. A couple years later, in 7th Grade, I made a friend on the first day of Mr. Aarestad’s band class who had much jazzier “moves” than I had ever heard, and I was immediately smitten, dying to learn what he knew. That started a lifelong friendship that involved exploration of contemporary drummers, as well as listening to all kinds of music. (Music featuring drums was the gateway drug, but we quickly moved into more classical realms, a shift that has stayed with me, the tail that wagged the dog become almost nothing but tail—tho I retain an appreciation for drums and drumming.)


Any focus on drums, especially with any kind of a jazz bent, leads inevitably to the great Buddy Rich, still considered probably the greatest drummer ever. But we listened to other people as well: Peter Erskine with Maynard Ferguson, Sonny Payne with Count Basie, Ed Thigpen with Oscar Peterson—as well as Nigel Olsson with Elton John and Liberty DiVitto with Billy Joel, anything with Steve Gadd, many others. Despite my big band orientation, one group I didn’t listen much to was Glenn Miller—maybe because my focus was so centered on drumming, and Miller was a more horn-oriented group. But along the way I ended up with a couple Glenn Miller recordings, both from the late 50s with bandleader (and drummer) Ray McKinley. I loved the more upbeat songs, and I especially remember loving a particular version of Miller’s longtime hit Kalamazoo.


Like all good obsessions, my fascination for the 1959 recording of Kalamazoo waxed and waned, but I remember listening carefully to it years ago and the appreciation of that study has stayed with me. 45 years later, I find myself zoomed in on it again. In addition to an updated arrangement (updated from his original '40s hit recording), and the letter-perfect execution by the band, I’m realizing that I’ve underestimated the drumming in the song—more than that, I'm thinking I've spent years missing a very different approach to drumming with a big band.





I remember reading that Buddy Rich himself expressed admiration for how Ray McKinley “drove” his big band, tho McKinley's approach is different and less ostentatious than anything I’ve heard Buddy attempt. Having said that, and before I discuss how I think this is so, it’s worth noting that the existing video clips of Ray McKinley at the drums make him seem much more circus showman and “entertainer” than Buddy’s more serious, all-business approach. McKinley raises his hands theatrically and does little wiggling flourishes (a '40s equivalent to a modern rock drummer twirling his sticks) and throws his arms out to the sides to no earthly purpose except to *look cool* to audiences of the time. It’s a showier version of what you might see on Lawrence Welk. So his approach to the drums was evidently NOT about avoiding ostentation. But—and I’m using Kalamazoo as my Exhibit A—his actual drumming is much more in a supporting role than Buddy’s. And his silly moves on video do not erase a really stellar performance on vinyl. 


There are stylistic things. His drums sound fairly low-pitch and are not loud, sounding like the calfskin heads and gut snare wires of 30 years previous. (Pictures show McKinley sitting at the kit with a steeply angled snare between his knees, very Chick Webb.) Where modern drums are individually miked, McKinley's kit seems just to be captured by the mikes set up for the other instruments. This contributes to the sense of his drums as a supporting, background role. He drives the band not with his ride cymbal but with a strong hi-hat swing, the cymbals held fairly loose by the foot and manipulated with the left hand while the right hand plays the rhythm. This technique harks back to the earlier era from which the Miller band came—again, like Chick Webb or Gene Krupa with Benny Goodman. By contrast, most drummers of the early ‘60s had shifted more to ride cymbal patterns as a foundation—and you hear that with any modern version today of the old songs: nobody drives a band with the hi-hat. His bass drum, instead of marking each quarter note quietly seems almost absent until needed for an emphasis. And this makes its use much more striking (it could be that without individual mikes you only hear the bass accents). Backbeats on the 2 & 4 are reserved only for climaxes, and then just for a bar or two. Emphasis.


I’m trying to decipher how or if these elements contribute to the success of the recording. Chicken or egg, there’s a clear sense that this driving and time-keeping is for the band’s benefit, enabling THEM to do the swinging. I think that’s the whole banana: his drumming is almost entirely focused on facilitating THE BAND swinging hard, whereas Buddy’s playing and drive are overwhelmingly front-and-center. Whereas one finishes a Buddy Rich song (let’s use the Sammy Nestico tune Ya Gotta Try from his “Class of ’77” album) with a breathless awareness of how hard Buddy has driven the band, you finish Kalamazoo with an awareness of how hard the band has swung the tune. You just naturally want to dance to it, where with Buddy you just stare in amazement.


Drums are an ostentatious instrument. Especially in modern times, the drummer is often center stage, encased in a large, imposing kit that makes a high proportion of the band’s noise. I think many aspiring drummers are drawn specifically to that noise and ostentation, and our own playing reflects this (like the high school girl who wants to sound like Mariah Carey—yes, I’m showing my age—by putting too much sugar on everything she sings, until it’s all sugar and no substance). I think I’ve always had a tendency to overplay, and I’m naturally drawn to the Buddy Riches and the Dave Weckls rather than the Elvin Jones or Art Blakey types. And maybe as I get older I begin to see the error in this thinking. While I don’t think anyone would consider the drums absent from McKinley’s 1959 Kalamazoo, he plays a more obviously supporting role than what Buddy Rich would have provided, and I think the song benefits from this. His playing is exquisitely musical, his time keeping deliciously metered, and the drums are used almost entirely to keep the band together and to accent. He steps up as needed—much like the trumpet section hits very specific notes at very specific times. And where I want to accent *everything* the band is doing, he lets THEM do the work and he accents either 1) what will help them hit their marks, or 2) points where the brass punches need a little extra for maximum effect. I’m used to Buddy emphasizing or underpinning everything, such that it’s almost like his band is supporting HIM. Which, as the named artist and the one people buy tickets to see, maybe they are.


All this calls into question my own approach to the instrument as being a constant, driving presence in any song, whereas McKinley seems to see the drums as a spice, an instrument intended to speak occasionally for emphasis. Is this an actual tectonic shift in how jazz was conceived or played? Or is it just the difference between the drummer as sideman versus the drummer as headliner? Ed Thigpen as part of the Oscar Peterson Trio is present at just about every moment, he and Ray Brown and Oscar sharing the microphone like the Andrews Sisters. He’s neither retiring nor just present for emphasis. Yet he’s not the star of anything either. I guess I struggle with how to place Ray McKinley who is doing (very competently) what drummers-as-sidemen always do, but driving from the very back seat in the bus, as it were. (And the whole discussion kind of sidesteps the different roles of the jazz drummer and the rock drummer.)


For decades I’ve read interviews with drummers talking about what the music needs and about playing what’s appropriate for the song, and I mostly dismissed that as lip service (tho guys like Steve Gadd or the late Jeff Porcaro have in fact played on recordings covering a huge range of styles). But nowhere have I heard someone drive a big band as skillfully as Ray McKinley without drawing any attention to his playing (at least not sonic attention). (Maybe it’s because he’s also the band’s singer, and that makes for attention enough. Fair question.) But I find myself asking why the song hits its marks so well, and how it does so when it avoids all the drumming conventions I instinctively favor? And that makes me ask what makes any song successful, and of course there's not one answer. But finding a different answer than what I'm used to seems like opening a door into a new room.



(This video does not very effectively support my thesis. The drums are at least as prominent here as any other instrument, and there's a strong emphasis on flash. But it does show Ray McKinley's style and musicianship.)